Comments for Why teach Old Joe Clark wrong?

Click here to add your own comments

Go with the D7
by: Alison

I fully concur that a child wants to play something that "sounds like something" and if Old Joe Clark sounds pretty close to the original using the D7 they feel like they have achieved an "actual" song.

My students often play a single fingered G chord, or a C9 instead of C so they can achieve playing a "whole song all the way through" - and folk songs have always evolved and changed, (I think you may be hard pressed to find original copyright owners, with over 90 verses written) - the 7 year old guitar student isn't going to get up on the Grand Ol' Opry stage and play the song using a D7 anytime soon - so let them enjoy, develop and nurture that passion for music - they'll learn about modes, and barre chords in plenty of time!

Nope, teach it like it is
by: Karl

There are scores, probably hundreds of songs that are equally as entertaining which wouldn't require a beginner to compromise the chord structure. Why not choose one that actually features G and D7?

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Do you have a funny story or something to share about this music.

Return to Why teach Old Joe Clark wrong?.

Sign up for "Take Note!" to see what's new every month.

Search Music-for-Music-Teachers: